Sunday, 24 July 2016

Why a shift away from fossil fuels is crucial

The climate pact signed by over 200 countries in Paris in the second week of December, setting a new goal to reach net zero emissions in the second half of the century, has hastened the transition away from fossil fuels and to a clean energy economy. Given the toll that burning coal and oil takes on climate and health of humans, a possible end of the fossil era is too good to be true.

However, for billions of people battered by air pollution caused by burning of fossil fuels—especially those in cities like Beijing, Delhi and Tehran that are choking with dirty emissions—it is likely to a long wait before the fossil fuel reduction targets are achieved. Over the past 200 years, humans have made a huge effect on the carbon cycle. One of the biggest changes to the carbon cycle has occurred as a result of the widespread use of fossil fuels. Burning fossil fuel releases carbon dioxide that adds carbon that has been out of circulation for millions of years directly to the atmosphere. Over the last two centuries, concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has hugely increased—in 1800, the carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere was about 280 parts per million, but now it has crossed 400 parts per million (‘parts per million’ points to the number of carbon dioxide particles out of every million molecules of air). Scientists believe that if humanity wishes to preserve a planet similar to that on which civilization developed and to which life on Earth is adapted, CO2 will need to be reduced from current levels to at least 350 ppm. The statistics are alarming: More than 4,000 Chinese die daily from air pollution.

In recent times use of vehicles run by fossil fuels have been reduced in many cities in Iran and Italy—besides the Delhi government’s decision to allow vehicles with alternative numbers to enter the city going ahead to reduce the number of vehicles by half—in efforts to clean up the toxic air. According to WHO, bad air causes premature deaths of more than 7 million people every year. India, whose rapidly growing population is hugely dependent on coal, is likely to have severe repercussions. A recent study found that 660 million Indians lose an average of 3.2 years of life due to exposure to air pollution. Experts warn that the tragedy that is unfolding is threatening to escalate going ahead.

The murky picture that is emerging as a result of reliance of fossil fuels has led to renewed focus on a shift towards alternative energy sources to run vehicles and in turn to enhanced development of electric vehicles (EVs) and vehicles run by hydrogen fuel cells (HFCVs).

The ongoing talks between Google and automaker Ford Motor Co to help build the Internet search company's autonomous cars is seen as part of the emerging initiatives to move towards vehicles that reduce emissions. Electric vehicles are cleaner than petroleum-fueled vehicles and seen as a partial solution to global warming. Using low carbon power electric car emissions are about a quarter of an inefficient gasoline car and half that of a top hybrid.

The recent launch of Tesla's long-awaited Model X electric car has created a lot of buzz. But given its huge pricing—$130,000 per car— it will be long wait for most environment-conscious car enthusiasts before seeing a palpable shift from fossil fuel-powered cars to EVs.

However, since the release of the all-electric Nissan Leaf in 2011, an increasing number of automakers have jumped on the battery-electric or plug-in hybrid bandwagon. Between 2016 and 2020, 24 new electric car models are expected to be launched in the US alone. Also, competition for the luxury Tesla Model S—which has about a 265-mile range between charges and costs between $70,000 and $105,000—has been mounting from mainstream car makers—Audi, Porsche and Mercedes are investing heavily on electric cars.

As competition grows tougher, price of EVs is expected to fall. In fact, besides battery cost, costs of motors and controllers have started dropping significantly. Taking a leaf from what happened to price of computers and smartphones, experts say as more electric cars are made, the sticker price of EVs will be equal to that of a similar-sized gasoline car within 10 years.

Along with EVs, HFCVs are also gaining acceptance and momentum. Global automobile major Toyota is betting big on hydrogen fuel cell cars and is aiming to encourage an ecosystem of fuel cell suppliers and hydrogen fueling stations to enhance its plans to focus more on manufacture of HFCVs.

However, the fact that HFCVs are more expensive—even if fuel-cells become cheaper and hydrogen production reach a critical mass, it will still be at least three times more expensive to power an HFCV car than an EV—will prove to be a drag on mass production of HFCVs in the near future.

However, as the perils of continued use of fossil fuels become more evident, countries across the globe are encouraging production of EVs and HFCVs, through tax cuts and subsidies, hoping vehicles driven by non-fossil fuels will help humanity combat climate change.

Deciphering the bankruptcy code

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2015, tabled in the parliament last week, assumes importance as one of the most important items on the government’s agenda after the constitutional amendment bill to roll out the Goods and Services Tax. As the logjam in the Parliament in the last two sessions for reasons that are frivolous at their core – opposition demand for resignation of External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj and two chief ministers over Lalit Modi row and Vyapam scam as well as the raucous created by the Congress over dragging Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi to court in the National Herald case – hurt the government’s plan to roll out GST by April 2016, the government hopes to save face by pushing the bankruptcy law.

For starters, the bankruptcy law is aimed at unifying and overhauling rules governing the liquidation or revival of ailing firms into a single code. The bankruptcy code will make it easier for companies to wind up failed businesses and bring India on a par with developed nations in terms of resolving bankruptcy issues. Currently, the country has no comprehensive law to deal with bankruptcy and insolvency, ranking the country lower than most nations in this respect.

India is placed 136 in terms of resolving insolvency in a World Bank list of 189 nations. Despite being, the world’s fastest-growing major economy, the country takes 4.3 years to resolve insolvency issues while Nepal does it in less than half the time. The bankruptcy code is expected to bring the time down to less than a year.

A single comprehensive law will also place India on a level-playing field along with developed countries. For example, the US has a bankruptcy code that comprises a few procedures offering quicker liquidation or reorganisation of businesses, including Chapter 7 that enables cases to be filed in bankruptcy courts, Chapter 11, which deals with reorganisation of businesses and Chapter 15 that addresses cross-border insolvencies. In the UK, 12 months after bankruptcy cases being filed assets are used to pay off debts or court-appointed administrators help firms turn around. In Germany, independent court-appointed insolvency practitioners help firms realise assets or reorganise the business.

As the Narendra Modi-led government is looking at enhancing the investment and credit mechanism through reforms, the code is also expected to simplify the whole issue of doing business in the country. As the government pushes to get the bankruptcy law passed at the earliest, one may wonder why after all the country needs such an initiative. For one, when a business winds up, it hurts employees, shareholders, lenders and the broader economy. Expediting the process of winding up of the business can help reduce the negative effect of such as eventuality. In Indian, the winding up process—
including assessing viability of the business, changing the management and selling off assets—is usually a long affair. Especially bankruptcy and winding down-related litigations carry on for several years, proving to be a drag on jobs, income generation and broader economic growth.

In fact, there are some related laws— Sick Industrial Companies Act or SICA and mechanisms such as Corporate Debt Restructuring or CDR, to address the issue of insolvency of firms. But these mechanisms have been ineffective due to improper implementation, enforcement and court delays.

A unified law with a focus on speedy closure will enable ailing companies to be either restructured or sold off with limited hassles. In many cases, assets can be better utilised and the firms can be restructured. Lenders and banks would be able to lend recovered money again, leading to better allocation of resources, which will have a ripple effect on the market and economy. A better insolvency ambience will also ensure enhanced availability of credit or funds for businesses by freeing up capital which in turn provides a leg-up to productivity.

Earlier, a panel headed by former law secretary T K Viswanathan has suggested a 180-day timeline to deal with applications for resolving cases of insolvency or bankruptcy. During this period, the management of troubled companies is recommended to be helped by resolution professionals who in turn will be supervised by a proposed regulator.

As per the recommendations of the panel, a debt recovery tribunal will act as the adjudicating authority over unlimited liability partnership firms, while the National Company Law Tribunal will be the adjudicating authority for firms with limited liability.

Also, the Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission has recommended the creation of a resolution corporation to monitor financial firms and to either change management to protect investors or depositors or close them altogether. This is aimed at preventing failure of large banks or financial institutions.

The proposed bankruptcy law is now sent for review after the government gave in to a demand by opposition members for a scrutiny by a parliamentary panel. The panel has been asked to submit its suggestions before the parliament begins its next session in February.

As passage of key bills, including bankruptcy code, will be crucial to take the government’s reforms agenda ahead, one hopes lawmakers will learn to behave responsibly, regain a sense of sanity and resist from resorting to reckless disruptive tactics that spoils crucial law making process that leads to huge losses to the exchequer besides stalling much-needed reforms.

Are MFIs striking a balance between profit and social responsibility?

In April this year, Kolkata-based Bandhan Financial Services emerged one among the only two entities (the other being IDFC) that were granted in-principle banking licences by the Reserve Bank of India after a hiatus of more than 10 years (no new Indian bank has been formed since 2004 when Yes Bank launched operations). The fact that Bandhan pipped around two dozen other applicants—including high-profile names such as Reliance Capital, controlled by billionaire Anil Ambani and Aditya Birla Nuvo, part of the Aditya Birla conglomerate—highlighted the government’s focus on providing banking licence to players that will ensure financial inclusion, by offering banking services to the bottom-of-the-pyramid group in rural areas who have little or no access to traditional banking services. Granting of banking licence to Bandhan has in fact proved to be a boost to the microfinance industry in the country which has been trying to gain momentum after the crisis in Andhra Pradesh in 2010 when the state government took tough regulatory measures, leading to the closure of many MFIs, after indebtedness to these firms prompted several farmers to commit suicide.

Microfinance, which was non-existent till early seventies, came into being in 1974 when Dr Muhammad Yunus, an economics professor born in Chittagong in Bangladesh (who went on to win the Nobel Peace Prize in 2006), loaned $27 to 42 poor women to pay off the loan they had taken from local loan sharks who charged exorbitant interest. That marked the birth of microfinance with the key idea of providing the poor small loans for their micro-enterprises to help them come out of poverty. The growth of Grameen Bank, set up by Yunus to help the poor fight poverty by becoming entrepreneurs, to an institution lending more than $1 billion a year to the have-nots, especially women, has proven that microfinance has a universal social applicability.

The microfinance industry in India witnessed significant growth in the years preceding the global financial crisis in 2008. SKS, which then was the country’s biggest microfinance firm with a $1.2 billion loan book, went public in July 2010. The $350 million offering was oversubscribed more than 13 times. But just a few months after SKS’ public offering, the AP microfinance crisis followed and things took an ugly turn. As farmers’ suicides abounded, AP government stiffened rules and all loans distributed in the state were written off, bringing the industry to a grinding halt as AP accounted for the bulk of microfinance lending disbursed in the country till then.

After years of muted growth, the industry has started showing signs of renewal, albeit under stricter norms issued by RBI. The investors have started responding to the sector’s renewed vigor. Last year, Indian microlenders raised a combined $470 million from investors such as Morgan Stanley Private Equity Asia and International Finance Corporation. Pune-based Suryoday Microfinance which raised Rs 27 crore led IFC; Bhubaneshwar-based Annapurna Microfinance which raised Rs 30 crore from Belgian Investment Company for Developing Countries and others and Bangalore-based Grameen Koota which raised Rs 80 crore from MicroVentures Investments are specific examples. Deals worth another $100 million are said to be in the pipeline, initiated by investors who are seeing MFIs as potential banks—the investment today may help them own part of a bank tomorrow—as illustrated by Bandhan.

While investors are bullish, there are those who say that the industry is headed in the wrong director from a social perspective. For decades, microfinance was mainly promoted by activists working for charities and NGOs, driven by a sense of social mission to improve the lot of the poor. But over the last decade, it has transformed into a global enterprise (the global commercial microfinance industry is expected to grow 20 per cent a year in the near future), with a portfolio worth $81 billion driven by profit more than social responsibility.

Also, the increasing interest rates charged by MFIs from impoverished borrowers—though global average interest rate is estimated at 37%, rates are as high as 70% in some markets while in India rates hover around 24-28%--seem to betray one of the key objectives of microfinance—providing small loans to the poor at an affordable cost.

However, going by the constructive and socially responsible role played by Grameen Bank in alleviating poverty in Bangladesh by helping transforming millions of poor into small entrepreneurs, one hopes the bank’s peers in India will follow suit, playing the dual role of agents of social change in fighting poverty while creating wealth through transparent business practices, thus contributing to overall economic growth.

Why a recovery in oil prices seems distant

The recent sharp dip of brent crude—the global oil benchmark—that breached the psychologically sensitive $30 a barrel mark to touch a 12-year low of $27.10 has stirred up lingering concerns about where the oil is headed and how that will affect the broader commodity market which has been languishing for some time now, pulling down growth forecasts globally.

For those who look for a upturn in oil prices, it has been a long wait—brent has slipped to below $30 a barrel level from more than $100 a barrel two years ago. The deep desperation among market players looking for the remotest positive cues was evident in the close to 8 per cent surge in brent prices seen this Thursday soon after Russia apparently said it is ready to discuss output levels with OPEC—opening the door for a deal with Saudi Arabia to revive oil prices—after vehemently opposing any chances of production cuts for months (till recently, it maintained that a cheap ruble, which has fallen to a record low against the US dollar, protected its energy industry from the worst of the oil slump). However, within hours, OPEC delegates said they knew nothing about a potential meeting with Russia next month, let alone output cuts, pushing prices back to $34 from a brief stay close to $36.

Russia’s unconfirmed comments are seen as a ploy to test the waters to gauge how OPEC members would respond to the idea of possible cuts. Even if Russia is truly keen on talks on likely production cuts with peers in the Middle East, there are a host of obstacles in its way before it reaches out to OPEC. The opposing views of Russia and Saudi Arabia on Syria—Russia has been supporting President Bashar Al-Assad while Saudi Arabia has been trying to push him out—make consensus between the two countries on terms of the discussion over oil price cuts unlikely. Saudi Arabia is also keen to defend its market share, especially in China where it has been battling with Russia to be the biggest oil supplier. Also, going by the spike in Russia’s oil production recently, it is hard to believe that Kremlin is sincere in its intention. Russia’s crude oil output is set to reach a post-Soviet record of 10.89 million barrels a day in a few weeks, up 83,000 barrels a day—the biggest monthly increase since September 2014.

There are several other reasons to believe why the unprecedented glut in oil production across the globe—resulting in unusual dips in prices—is likely to continue. Following the lifting of years of nuclear sanctions, Iran is ramping up oil production—last week it signed a deal with Total SA to ship crude to France. Also, acute cash crunch may force OPEC peers Angola, Nigeria and Venezuela to refrain from output cuts as they scramble to sell as much oil as they can to stay afloat. Besides, production from Iraq continue to rise unabated—the country recorded record output in December, with its fields in the central and southern regions producing as much as 4.13 million barrels a day, and it is planning to hike output going ahead.

As production is unlikely to slow down in near future, a growing number of analysts expect prices to remain sluggish—Standard Chartered expects oil prices to remain volatile in the near future as the underlying negative sentiment in the market seems little changed. Joining a host of banks that that have trimmed oil outlook due to the excess supply in the market, HSBC and UniCredit slashed oil price forecasts for 2016. Despite some near-term bullish signals, most analysts expect oil markets to remain oversupplied, keeping prices mostly at current levels. In fact, a few of them even expect oil process to touch $20 a barrel.

Such pessimism is not unwarranted as the world currently remains oversupplied by roughly 1 million to 2 million barrels per day. A majority of analysts expect glut to persist through the first half of 2016. Tighter monetary policy in the US and the euro area is expected to weigh on global oil demand at least for a few quarters more. The slump seen by China and its spillover effect across Asia and the rest of the world too is likely to play spoilsport.

With the shale revolution, the US is now among the top oil producers globally—it produces 9.3 million barrels a day against Russia’s 11.1 million barrels a day and Saudi Arabia’s 10.3 million barrels a day. The surge of the US as a key oil producer has unsettled the OPEC centric world view when it comes to oil production and over-supply driven by unbridled shale oil production, among other factors, is likely to keep prices languished, though a minority among oil watchers may not be surprised if prices surge back to $50-60 a barrel by the end of the year.

Plummeting oil prices – who stands to gain?

As this piece is being written, the global benchmark Brent crude fell to a six-year nadir of $45.23 a barrel, the lowest since March 2009 amid forecast by top investment banks including Goldman Sachs warning a further dip to $40 a barrel where it may stay for most of the first half of this year. The oil prices have now fallen by more than half since June, when they stood at $115 per barrel.

A slew of reasons are cited for the steep fall in oil prices. Production from North American shale companies has increased the supply of oil and gas, dragging prices down. Slowing global economic demand and a surging dollar against a range of global currencies are two other key reasons why oil prices have declined significantly.

Usually when oil process dip, Opec, the oil producing countries' cartel, tends to respond with a cut in output, thus boosting prices. However, at its most recent meeting in November, top oil producer Saudi Arabia coerced other member countries to retain oil output at the current levels, pushing oil prices further down. The surprising move by Saudi Arabia was triggered by a convoluted reason. It’s relatively cheap to pump oil out of Middle East countries including Saudi Arabia and Kuwait. But it's more expensive to extract oil from shale formations in the US. Therefore a continued fall in oil prices will make US oil production unprofitable and hence should push some of the US oil producing firms out of business. The subsequent dip in production of US oil will then help stabilise prices. Essentially, Saudi Arabia simply doesn’t want its market share to be hurt even at the cost of falling prices and the subsequent effect on the country’s GDP.

Though Opec member Venezuela subsequently said it will work with Saudi Arabia for a recovery in oil prices, no measures has been taken by the countries so far.

For much of the past decade, oil prices were high — bouncing around $100 per barrel since 2010 — because of soaring oil consumption in countries like China and conflicts in key oil nations like Iraq. Prices surged as oil production couldn't keep up with the rising demand.

High prices encouraged companies in the US and Canada to start drilling for new, hard-to-extract crude in shale formations in North Dakota and oil sands in Alberta, which slowly lead to a glut in oil production. At the same time, demand for oil in Europe dipped as the its economy weakened. In addition, countries like Iraq started producing more oil which also added to the glut. As in any other demand-supply mismatch scenario, production soon overtook demand and by 2014, supply far outpaced demand, speeding up oil’s downward journey.

Low prices are good for oil consumers in countries like Japan or the US. But it will hit hard nations reliant on oil sales. For instance, it is estimated that Russia's GDP will shrink at least 4.5 per cent in 2015 if oil stayed at $60 per barrel. Falling oil prices have also caused the ruble's value to collapse, triggering panic across  the country.

There is concern that the oil crash could cause Venezuela, whose economy is heavily dependent on oil revenue, to default. Even better-prepared countries like Saudi Arabia could face heavy pressure if oil prices stay low.

For India, which imports 75 per cent of its oil, the price fall will ease its current account deficit. The cost of India's fuel subsidies is also expected to fall by $2.5 billion if oil prices stay low. Will global oil prices stay low is a question that is in the minds of industry watchers. A possible political turmoil in oil producing countries such as Iraq and Libya, an faster-than-expected growth in Chinese  economy, an economic rebound in Europe and a decision by Saudi Arabia to cut production are among a few scenarios that may lead to a turnaround in oil prices.

Venture capital and gender gap

A recent study found that only less than 3 per cent of comments on venture capital blogs focusing on US financial and startup space are by women. While it is commonly understood that the proportion of women in the tech sector is low, this study showed that the engagement of women with the VC industry is even lower. Another recent study found that only about 15 per cent of US companies receiving venture-capital investment included at least one woman in the executive team. If this is the case in a mature startup ecosystem like the US, one can imagine how inadequate the representation of women in a nascent startup ecosystem like the one in India which is slowly catching up with the emerged markets in terms of cash flow to VC-funded enterprises.

Of the top VC firms operating in India, Accel Partners India, Bessemer Venture Partner, Blume Ventures, Helion venture Partners, IDG VC India, Inventus Capital, Nexus Venture Partners, Matrix Partners India, SAIF Partners and Sequoia Capital India have no women partners or managing directors while Kalaari Capital and Seedfund have just one each.
    
Among reasons for the limited representation of women at the top strata of VC firms—and thus the nature of decisions that are made or not made in the country’s startup ecosystem, which will lead to wealth creation and drive growth in the long run—is the fact that the ‘men club’ that leads most VC firms tends to opt for people like them when it comes to recruiting talent.

Secondly, since VC industry in India is at a nascent stage and is not well understood, women perceive VC jobs as something that belong to the area of hardcore finance and number crunching rather than a business model evaluation, and hence tend to stay away from it. Another reason is the lack of awareness at business school level which results in very few women taking up internships at VC firms that will help them mould their career in the VC space at an early stage.  

Since Indian startup ecosystem is still at its cradle, even those women who would want to take up a corporate career have not got enough opportunity to see how investments in startups would turn around in the long run and how innovative ideas can give birth to multi-billion dollar companies in the future, unlike in mature markets like the US where there are ample examples of startups, which were bit players at certain point in time, emerging as corporate behemoths valued at billions of dollars. Mobile-app-based radio taxi aggregator Uber, which raised a recent funding round at a staggering valuation of $40 billion within five years of being launched, is just one example of startups turning billion dollar opportunities for VC firms.  

More cash flow to startups owned by women entrepreneurs will happen only when a larger percentage of decision makers at VC firms become women who would want to nurture fellow women as future corporate leaders.

Another drag is lack of concentrated efforts from the government to nurture VC investments and support the startup ecosystem. Despite the ‘Make in India’ campaign, the recent Budget presented a miserly picture when it came to allocation to nurture startups.

However, the silver lining is the new law announced by market regulator SEBI, mandating at least one woman on the board of publicly-listed companies though it exempted SMEs having equity share capital of up to Rs 10 crore and net worth not exceeding Rs 25 crore.

Also, corporate India seems to be slowly awakening to the need for more women in the ranks of the top honchos. The Indian unit of telecom firm Vodafone recently said it increased the percentage of women employees in its workforce to 20 per cent currently from 14 per cent two years ago and will hire even more women across levels and functions. Group Executive Council of the Tata Group too is said to be planning to double the count of women to over 300,000 from 115,000 currently in its 540,000-strong workforce.

One hopes VC players in the country, too, take a cue from the SEBI directive and what larger industry peers like Vodafone and Tata Group are trying to do bring about a change when it comes to ensuring women representation in the country’s investment space.

How Modi government used India Economic Summit to showcase its reforms agenda

The recently concluded World Economic Forum’s three-day India Economic Summit focusing on the nation’s economic prospects and social development (organised along with industry body Confederation of Indian Industry in New Delhi) was an opportune platform for the newly formed Narendra Modi-led government to emphatically tell  global investors and the industry and economy watchers that it is determined to bring a clutch of path-breaking reforms that will transform the country from a ‘paralysed’ economy to a high-growth juggernaut and a world power.

In fact, the Modi government had a string of pro-reform measures—which it has already initiated—under its belt to showcase at the summit. First it tried to make the mammoth slouching bureaucracy accountable. Then came the ‘Make in India’ campaign which aims to transform the country to the world’s factory and create 100 million jobs by 2022, which was followed by the politically sensitive decision to cut in diesel subsidy which is expected to help hugely reduce fiscal deficit and the move to open the coal sector to the private sector.

The significant representation from the government at the summit—close to half a dozen ministers from Modi’s cabinet, including finance minister Arun Jaitley and power and coal minister Piyush Goyal,  addressed the summit—helped sent a strong message that the steps that have already been initiated are just a beginning. This was amply conveyed by Jaitley who inspired hope among the investor community—at home and spread across the globe—by assuring a transparent and rule-based policy environment and promising to continue to push for economic policy changes to make regulations in India more business-friendly. He touched upon two key expected moves to help push this change. First, the government’s resolve to aggressively continue its divestment agenda—Jaitley said the government is open to completely privatising loss-making public sector undertakings (the country has 79 loss-making PSUs of which 49 are sick enterprises) and the government is aiming to bring down its equity in public sector banks to about 52 per cent. Second, the decision to push ahead with reforming the land purchase law, blamed by the industry and business community for slowing industrial projects. The complex procedures of the law—which seeks to set fair compensation for loss of livelihood for farmers who sell their land to industrial or infrastructure projects—have made it hard for companies to acquire land for large-scale industrial projects.

The optimism was echoed by World Economic Forum's managing director Philipp Rosler who told a business daily that Modi government seems to have a strategic vision and the right approach to reform and that the ‘standstill’ like sentiment about India that prevailed before the elections has turned around. Rosler said Modi government has shown that it has a long term perspective and wants to go step by step which is much more realistic than promise everything and achieve nothing.

However, critics are as vocal as supporters and fans and say that the new government has failed to live up to the expectations stirred during Modi’s glossy election campaign trail studded with rhetoric (bullet trains, 100 smart cities, et al). They also say the government failed to use the India Economic Summit as a platform to announce ‘big bang’ reforms desperately needed to take the country ahead towards high voltage growth after years of stagnated momentum, scams and policy paralysis.

Jaitley tried to counter this argument at the summit when he said that consistently and relentlessly pursuing economic reforms, which the government is trying to do, is more practically feasible that a few sweeping big bang steps. It seems, for a change, the investors—in India and elsewhere—have enough reasons to believe what Jaitley is saying.